Scoop Makhathini’s Ranking of the Best SA Rappers of All Time Places AKA in a Sole Dominant Position. This latest discussion around the stature of South African hip-hop has gained attention as Scoop Makhathini released his list of the country’s premier rappers, with AKA taking the lead over some of the genre’s most pivotal figures.
In a recent interview with S0ciety, the seasoned hip-hop analyst explained his methodology, arguing that true greatness is not solely rooted in lyrical skill. For Scoop, an artist’s contribution is evaluated through originality, cultural impact, musical prowess, lifespan within the business, and stage charisma, alongside their capability of paving the way for the next generation.
Scoop clarified that his rankings could evolve, acknowledging the potential for fresh talent to alter the landscape as they progress in their careers.
“This list is not fixed,” he noted, indicating that new artists might rise in the ranks as their accomplishments accumulate. He also gave a nod to YoungstaCPT for his contributions.
Below is Scoop’s assessment of various icons in South African hip-hop.
5. Stogie T and A-Reece
Stogie T has secured his position due to his advanced technique and lyrical richness. Scoop asserts that he stands among the elite lyricists globally, comparing him to figures like Common, Black Thought, Royce da 5’9”, and Lupe Fiasco.
“For someone from the southernmost tip of Africa to rap at a level that can rival anybody in the biggest arenas overseas, he has to be there,” Scoop stated.
A-Reece shares the fifth rank, with Scoop acknowledging his influence on the independent hip-hop scene and his skill at carving a niche without adhering to conventional industry practices. His lyrical talent and autonomy have significantly impacted how emerging artists perceive their careers.
However, Scoop mentions that A-Reece’s introverted persona may hinder his overall ranking, particularly within a space where visibility and industry connections are vital.
4. Kwesta and K.O
Kwesta occupies the fourth position due to his adaptability, sharp lyricism, and ease in transitioning between English and local dialects. Scoop describes him as a rapper admired by peers, noting his streetwise punchlines and a discography that has proven its resilience over time.
Beyond his artistry, Scoop commends Kwesta’s business acumen and personal life management, pointing out how he balances family and a thriving career while upholding his cultural relevance.
K.O shares this rank, celebrated for his lyrical prowess, adaptability, and sustained commercial success. His business perspective has ensured his relevance in the industry, securing opportunities well after many of his peers have faded from the spotlight.
3. ProKid and Nasty C
ProKid’s impact on the hip-hop landscape in South Africa lands him among the all-time greats. Scoop believes the late musician played a crucial role in challenging the narrative that English-speaking artists were more sophisticated than their vernacular counterparts.
Through his work, ProKid illustrated that vernacular hip-hop can be intelligent, refined, and culturally rich while maintaining its identity.
Scoop connects ProKid’s legacy to influences on artists like Kwesta and Touchline, emphasizing landmark achievements such as the Fish Eagle deal and airport billboard as pivotal in showcasing hip-hop’s commercial appeal.
Nasty C holds the third rank for his exceptional skill and his ability to convey intricate emotions in his music. Scoop likens Nasty C’s emotional narrative style to that of Drake, noting their shared capacity to express vulnerability and personal growth relatable to audiences.
Despite Nasty C’s inclination towards an American sound, Scoop maintains that his artistry and lived experiences are distinct.
“Nasty is in the class of the world,” he asserted.
2. HHP and Okmalumkoolkat
HHP, affectionately known as Jabba, ranks second for his pivotal role in elevating South African hip-hop into the mainstream. Scoop regards him as the genre’s first genuine crossover star, one who succeeded despite not fitting the traditional mold of a rap celebrity.
Originating from outside Johannesburg and blending English with local languages, HHP’s musical talent and charm enabled him to resonate with broad audiences. His commanding stage presence influenced subsequent generations, including Cassper Nyovest.
For Scoop, HHP demonstrated that success in the industry does not require flashy branding.
Okmalumkoolkat also takes the second spot due to his considerable cultural impact. Scoop identifies him as someone who has pushed hip-hop beyond music, challenging established norms in fashion, visual arts, album design, and creativity.
Through projects like Holy Oxygen, Okmalumkoolkat redefined vernacular rap to make it seem modern and globally pertinent without simply mimicking American influences. His innovative strategies have established him as a compelling creative whose influence stretches beyond music.
1. AKA
According to Scoop Makhathini, AKA holds a unique place above all other South African rappers.
The legacy of the late Supa Mega is central to this perspective. Scoop posits that AKA began his journey in hip-hop focusing on battle rap but later embraced a more holistic understanding of what it means to succeed in the music industry.
Taking cues from HHP’s successful path, AKA understood the significance of producing great music in addition to impressive lyrics. This pivotal realignment was instrumental in his evolution and set new benchmarks within the industry.
Scoop acknowledges that AKA raised the bar for live shows, music videos, branding, commercial drive, and the overall aesthetic of South African hip-hop.
“If Jabba, Pro and those guys were the first money in hip-hop, AKA was the second springboard,” he noted.
With his artistry, image, and striking presence, AKA opened the door for the notion of South African hip-hop artists achieving pop star status. He transformed the genre into a broader cultural and commercial phenomenon, influencing how musicians develop their sound, their business strategies, and their public personas.
For Scoop, AKA’s impact extends beyond his musical output. It redefined what a South African rapper could strive to become.
Although the ranking reflects Scoop’s individual viewpoint, his rationale provides a wider lens on the attributes that have shaped the nation’s hip-hop narrative. He concedes that the list may adapt as new talents carve out their paths, but, for now, AKA stands as his unequivocal number one.
With YoungstaCPT earning an honourable mention and various generations represented, this discourse emphasizes the diverse ways artists have contributed to the progress of South African hip-hop, encompassing lyrical innovation, cultural representation, commercial achievements, and broader societal influence.
