The National Energy Regulator of South Africa (NERSA) has revealed that residents and businesses in five municipalities are eligible for refunds due to improper electricity tariff charges.
During court proceedings, the regulator accepted responsibility for approving the incorrect 2025/26 tariffs for Johannesburg, Ekurhuleni, Nelson Mandela Bay, Emfuleni, and Madibeng, acknowledging that these were based on flawed calculations.
These municipalities rank among the ten largest in South Africa, with Brits being the most populated town in Madibeng, which also encompasses Hartbeespoort.
NERSA further acknowledged that it failed to adequately verify the data provided by the municipalities, which was used to substantiate the tariff increases.
The discrepancies were spotlighted during a Pretoria High Court deliberation on November 9, 2026, instigated by a group of significant industrial electricity consumers against NERSA.
The applicants included Coega Steels, Mpact, Autocast SA, along with the Casting, Forging and Machining Cluster of South Africa.
For instance, in Nelson Mandela Bay, the tariffs set for businesses were found to be 76% above the actual cost incurred by the metro for electricity provision.
Contrarily, the City of Ekurhuleni has contested the refund claims, citing financial constraints that hinder its ability to reimburse customers.
Legal representatives for Mpact suggested that refunds be restricted only to those parties involved in the lawsuit. NERSA disagreed, maintaining that restricting the refunds could unfairly omit other consumers who also incurred unlawful charges.
It contended that corrections should extend to all electricity users within the impacted municipalities.
To mitigate potential financial strain on municipal budgets, NERSA requested the court to allow for a gradual implementation of the tariff corrections over several years.
Despite imposing inflated tariffs, four out of the five municipalities currently owe money for bulk electricity purchases from Eskom, with Johannesburg being the exception. The city, however, had previously fallen behind on its payments but cleared its R5.25 billion debt to Eskom in August 2026.
The civil rights organization AfriForum has consistently alerted NERSA and municipal authorities regarding the repercussions of allowing consumers to be billed under incorrect and disputed tariffs.
Administrative crisis coming — AfriForum

In 2024, AfriForum warned that NERSA was heading towards a potential administrative crisis by permitting over 100 municipalities to raise their electricity tariffs without conducting necessary cost assessments.
This warning came just before Eskom adjusted its pricing, imposing a 12.74% hike for bulk electricity sales as part of the yearly municipal tariff changes effective from July 1.
The Pretoria High Court determined that NERSA acted unlawfully when it sanctioned tariff applications from 112 electricity distributors for the 2024/25 period without adequate cost studies.
The legal challenge was initiated by AfriForum, which contested NERSA’s approvals that lacked a complete supply cost analysis, claiming it violated the Electricity Regulation Act.
NERSA subsequently filed an application to appeal the court’s decision, asserting that the appeal would permit municipalities to proceed with the tariff increases.
Morné Mostert, AfriForum’s head of local government affairs, remarked that although NERSA’s interpretation of the law was technically correct, approving the tariff increases was unwise.
He noted, “You can imagine what would happen if a municipality that already struggles to meet basic requirements in regulations and law must now go back in their financial systems and credit people.”
Mostert emphasized that while refunds could be efficiently processed for postpaid accounts, doing so for prepaid customers could pose significant challenges. Prepaid customers often represent lower-income groups who may bear the brunt of this issue.
In 2025, AfriForum succeeded in another legal challenge against NERSA after the regulator incorrectly validated the electricity tariff hikes for the five implicated municipalities as per the court’s November 2026 ruling.
This earlier 2025 case served as the foundation for industrial clients seeking refunds, resulting in an administrative headache for the municipalities involved, exactly as AfriForum had predicted.
Other organizations that have contested NERSA’s tariff policies and municipal applications include the business chambers of Nelson Mandela Bay and Pietermaritzburg.
While larger businesses typically receive significant discounts on electricity tariffs, smaller to medium-sized enterprises often pay rates comparable to households.
Don’t miss the latest news
